What are the Benefits or Drawbacks of Home Care Over a Nursing Home?

Families often debate whether home care is a better option for their loved ones over nursing homes. To give you a clear idea, we will explore how home care and nursing homes work and compare one’s benefits and drawbacks over another one.

Remember that each option has its own set of advantages and challenges. As your elderly individual might get chronic health conditions, they require the best support systems available. So, read our guide and decide which one can grab the best benefits.

How do Home Care and Nursing Homes work?

Since 2022, there have been more than 12,000 active home health agencies in NY. Some of them are home-based services, and some of them are clinic-based services. Let’s look at their operational process:

  • Home Care: Home care sends professional caregivers directly to your home. Their services range from medical care to daily activities like bathing, dressing, and meal preparation. So, the patients receive personal care in a familiar environment. 
  • Nursing Homes: Nursing homes are facilities designed to offer constant supervision or medical attention. These facilities provide 24/7 care, including medical monitoring, meal services, and recreational activities.

The operational process reflects which type of benefit you could get from the homecare service and nursing home service. Although people are seemingly moving to the homecare service.

Why is Home Care Seemed Beneficial Over a Nursing Home?

The Compound Annual Growth Rate (CAGR) of the home healthcare market is expected to be 7.96% from 2024 to 2030. During this time, the popularity of the top-rated home health aide agencies in Queens NY, like DHCareNY, proves that families tend to rely on caregiving services. 

Besides, you should not think of the neatness and cleanliness of your home if you take a home care service. If you find a safe person for caregiving, you can save yourself from a lot of hassle, like visiting a nursing home or consulting doctors.

The Benefits of Home Care Over Nursing Home

At-home care, the main benefit is seeing other family members and the environment. But that’s not all. There are some more facilities you can get from it. Here is a basic list of facilities from home care—

  • Home care helps individuals to remain in their own homes. So, there is emotional well-being and comfort present during the medical service and therapies.
  • Caregivers can focus on the specific needs of the individual to suit their requirements and discuss them with family members. This way, nothing remains unchecked.
  • Families can actively participate in the care process through some official programs. As a result, the care increases even more than in a nursing home or hospital.
  • In many cases, home care can be more affordable than nursing homes due to not having any monthly charge, especially when only part-time assistance is needed.
  • Individuals maintain their routines and enjoy a sense of autonomy in their daily lives. Otherwise, they have to visit cabins and pathology centers repeatedly.

The homecare service providers also have some benefits for them! They do not have to keep too many rooms for their employees and patients at their institutions. It can cost in a large amount.

The Drawbacks of Home Care Over Nursing Home

The nursing home offers some unique services that cannot be instantly available at-home care, such as— doctor’s availability and quarantine. 

  • Home care might not be ideal for individuals requiring constant medical attention.
  • Finding reliable and skilled caregivers can be a challenge for hundreds of companies.
  • Homes may lack the medical equipment available in nursing homes in an emergency.

It’s not that the list of demerits is less than the merits of home care, and for that reason, people are opting for home care! Even in some conditions, nursing homes could be more life savers in critical moments of a patient. But, home care gives more mental and financial freedom to overcome the nursing home.

Home Care vs. Nursing Home: Which Contains Most Benefits?

Both home care and nursing home have their merits without any doubt. Apart from getting constant medical support, we think home care is a little more effective for a critical patient. You cannot deny that your elder individual needs family and emotional support for the motivation of quick recovery. And you can get this from home care only.

On the other hand, nursing homes are more suited for individuals with severe health conditions requiring round-the-clock supervision. However, the ‘institutional’ environment and lack of personal attention can sometimes diminish the quality of life for residents.

Conclusion

Ultimately, home care combines the best of professional assistance with the emotional benefits of staying connected to one’s home and family. More importantly, now there has been a rise of insurance based health care agencies. So, a family member can also become the caregiver of another family member after passing the test instead of hiring an unknown employee.

Scroll to Top