what is  Galling in CNC Machining

Introduction to Galling in CNC Machining

Galling is a severe form of wear that occurs when metal surfaces slide against each other under high pressure and friction. This phenomenon is particularly prevalent in CNC machining environments, where improper tooling or coolant strategies can lead to excessive heat and material adhesion.

I first encountered galling when machining stainless steel couplings; the threads appeared rough and torn. This experience prompted me to explore its causes and solutions to minimize downtime and material wastage. In this guide, I share insights and best practices for preventing galling in CNC machining, covering material selection, process parameters, lubrication, and surface treatments.

Understanding the Causes of Galling in CNC Machining

Galling occurs due to friction, temperature, and material properties. Ductile metals like stainless steel, aluminum, and titanium are particularly susceptible, as they form adhesive bonds under pressure.

Materials Prone to Galling

Certain metals exhibit higher tendencies for galling due to their ductility and thermal conductivity. Below is an overview:

Stainless steel, with its poor thermal conductivity, often accumulates heat, exacerbating galling. Titanium and aluminum present similar issues if machining parameters are not optimized.

Friction and Heat Generation

Friction and heat are primary drivers of galling. High friction increases surface adhesion, while excessive heat softens metal surfaces, increasing their tendency to weld together. Managing these factors through speed, feed rates, and cooling is essential.

High-pressure cooling and optimized feed rates can mitigate these risks significantly.

Surface Roughness and Galling

Rougher surfaces create more contact points, leading to localized stress and increased galling potential. Achieving a lower surface roughness (Ra < 1.6 µm) in stainless steel and aluminum machining minimizes the chances of adhesion.

Lubrication and Cooling Strategies

The choice of coolant and lubrication significantly impacts galling prevention. Water-based coolants excel in cooling but may lack lubricity, while oil-based fluids reduce metal-to-metal contact.

• Anti-Seize Compounds: Applied to threads and fasteners to prevent cold welding.
• High-Pressure Coolants: Flush chips away and reduce heat buildup.
• Extreme Pressure Additives (EP): Improve lubricity, especially in stainless steel and titanium machining.

How to Reduce Galling in CNC Machining

A multi-faceted approach involving process optimization, material selection, and tool modifications is required to minimize galling.

Process Optimization

Speeds and Feeds

Contrary to common belief, slowing down isn’t always the best solution. Higher feed rates with moderate spindle speeds often result in cleaner shearing and lower friction.

Toolpath Strategy

• Climb Milling: Reduces heat and friction compared to conventional milling.
• Depth of Cut (DOC): Avoid shallow cuts that cause rubbing; opt for deeper passes where applicable.

Fixturing and Workholding

Ensuring workpiece stability prevents vibration-induced friction, reducing galling risks.

Material Selection and Surface Treatment

When possible, selecting lower-galling materials or using treatments like electropolishing can help. Heat treatment also enhances hardness, minimizing adhesion.

Tooling and Cooling Strategies

• Coated Carbide Tools: TiAlN, TiCN, and DLC coatings improve wear resistance.
• Sharp Edges: Prevent excessive friction; replace dull tools promptly.
• High-Pressure Coolant: Enhances chip evacuation and lowers heat buildup.

Case Studies: Real-World Applications

Automotive: Stainless Steel Pistons

• Problem: 304 stainless steel brake pistons experienced galling.
• Solution: Switched to 17-4 PH, applied DLC coating, and improved surface finish.
• Outcome: Galling eliminated, smoother braking performance.

Aerospace: Titanium Wing Brackets

• Problem: Titanium bolts in wing brackets seized due to galling.
• Solution: Reduced RPM, increased feed rate, used anti-seize lubricants.
• Outcome: Brackets remained intact during repeated vibration tests.

Medical Devices: Surgical Instruments

• Problem: 316L stainless steel instruments developed galling after sterilization.
• Solution: Switched to electropolishing, added CrN coatings.
• Outcome: Friction reduced, galling eliminated.

Best Practices and Checklist

1. Material Selection: Choose galling-resistant metals when possible.
2. Process Optimization: Balance RPM and feed rate to minimize friction.
3. Surface Finishing: Grind, polish, or electropolish surfaces for smooth contact.
4. Tooling and Coatings: Use sharp, coated carbide tools.
5. Lubrication and Cooling: Opt for high-pressure coolants and anti-seize compounds.
6. Inspection and Documentation: Track successful parameters to refine processes.

Conclusion

If you need custom parts, you can contact Want.net for reliable machining services.

Galling is a persistent challenge in CNC machining, but with strategic planning, it can be managed effectively. By optimizing process parameters, selecting appropriate materials, and leveraging coatings and lubricants, machinists can significantly reduce galling-related failures. Continuous documentation and refinement of machining strategies ensure long-term success in preventing galling issues.